BROOMFIELD AND KINGSWOOD PARISH COUNCIL

[ Back to: Home Page | Parish Council ]

Minutes of a Meeting of the Broomfield and Kingswood Parish Council held at Kingswood Village Hall on Monday 7th August 2008

_____________________________________________________________________________

Present:

Cllr Nelson Bowker (NB)                                                Cllr Peter Coleman (PC)

Cllr Mike Evans (ME)                                                     Cllr Neil Harrison (NH)

Cllr Dave Law (DL – Chairman)                                    Cllr Pat Lyne (PL)                              (6)

Sue Wotton (SW – Clerk)

Cllr Peter Parvin (PP – Leeds Ward Councillor)

PC Stuart Thomas

Nigel Cuming – Editor The Echo, Rural Transport Warden

52  members of the public.  

7.35pm - Cllr Law introduced himself and welcomed members of the public.   Cllr Law explained that in respect of Item 4 of the Agenda - Affordable Housing - having declared a prejudicial interest he would be required to leave the room for that Item, but should it be agreed to move that Item to the beginning of the evening, before the Meeting of the Parish Council was opened, and to hear the presentation at this stage, by Jennifer Shaw (Rural Housing Enabler) and Emmanuel Ogedengbe (Orbit Group), he could be present.   Cllr Law asked for and received confirmation from Cllr Parvin that this was the case, and it was agreed by other Councillors, that the presentation be brought forward and go ahead outside the Parish Council Meeting.  Cllr Law then introduced and welcomed Jennifer, Emmanuel and Richard Daniels (Architect).

Jennifer outlined the history of Affordable Housing which had lead to the current position in regard to the site at Ashford Drive being identified as both suitable and available, and answered  many questions posed by both members of the public and Councillors.   Strong opposition was expressed regarding the Ashford Drive site, primarily due to it being outside the village envelope.   A petition was presented – retained by the Clerk.

At the conclusion of the presentation and questions, Cllr Law thanked Jennifer, Emmanuel and Richard for attending.   They thanked the Parish Council for allowing them to attend and give their presentation and stated they would be happy to continue to support and work with the Parish Council in respect of Affordable Housing. 

Cllr Law opened the Meeting at 9.28pm

Apologies for Absence

Cllr Sue Clarke (SC)   -   holiday                     Cllr Jody Evans (JE – Vice Chair)   -   holiday

Cllr Beth Hendy (BH)  -   holiday                     Val Clark – Street Warden

41.       Personal & Prejudicial Interests ( i.e. Pecuniary / Non-Pecuniary)

Cllr Coleman   -  Village Hall, Village Hall Notice Board

Cllr Law           -  Affordable Housing

Pat Lyne          -  Village Hall, Kent Messenger

Clerk                -  Village Hall Notice Board

42.       Minutes of the Meeting held 3rd July 2006

The Minutes of the last Meeting held 3rd July were read and signed as correct, proposed by Cllr Bowker, seconded by Cllr Coleman, and signed by the Chairman.

43.       Actions / Matters Arising from Meeting held 3rd July 2006

(i)         Clerk has written to Chief Superintendent Hope on behalf of Parish Council and residents and has requested the letter and relevant addresses be published in the September issue of the K&B Village News for information of residents who may also wish to write – copy attached

(ii)        Cllr M Evans has written to KCC regarding publication ‘Towards 2010’ – copy attached

(iii)       Clerk has completed and circulated draft Football Club Contract – see Minute 51 (iii)

(iv)       Clerk has organized Pensioners’ outing for Tuesday 19th September – see Minute 54

44.       Affordable Housing

Cllr Harrison consulted Local Council Administration 7th Edition, 10.13 (page 99) with regard to making an immediate decision on whether to proceed with the Ashford Drive site, or abandon it.   Cllr Harrison stated that no decision could be made without due notice, thus fair on both sides.  

In respect of this, the following general points were raised:

Ø      Planning Permission has not been submitted in respect of the Ashford Drive site

Ø      the Parish Council must make a decision whether to continue in respect of Ashford Drive, or seek to find an alternative site, but cannot be taken this evening as not an Agenda item

Ø      the Parish Council has, in the past, objected to all Planning Applications outside the village envelope

Ø      there has to be ‘exceptional sites’ or Affordable Housing would never be realized

Ø      is the public objection in respect of this particular site ( Ashford Drive) or any ‘exceptional site’ outside the village envelope around the village

Ø      the Parish Council should not give up its search for a suitable site for Affordable Housing for those who want to be able to live in Kingswood

Ø      the site at Ashford Drive should not be abandoned altogether at this stage, but put to one side whilst enquiries continue to identify another site

Ø      proper consideration should be given to the feelings expressed by the public

Ø      time should be taken for Councillors to reflect and not make a quick decision  

Following this discussion, Cllr Law then asked Councillors what they wanted to do and each  expressed their views.   General opinion was that an Affordable Housing scheme for the Parish was still wanted, but the strength of feeling of residents should be considered and ideally an alternative site sought.

There came a point during this discussion, when Cllr Harrison reminded Cllr Law that he should leave the meeting for this Agenda item, which he did, and Cllr Harrison then took the Chair.

Further dialogue ensued, and it was finally proposed and agreed that no decision should be made this evening on whether to abandon the Ashford Drive site altogether, enquiries to find a suitable site should continue, and the subject should be made an Agenda item for the Meeting of the Parish Council on 2nd October.                                                                 ACTION - Clerk

Cllr Law rejoined meeting at 9.48pm  

45.       Tall Trees Play Area

The Clerk had received a complaint from David Stubbles about delays to progress.   Cllr Law reported that the fencer should have started the work at the weekend (5th/6th August) and he will check that this is so.   Cllr Law has now passed the paperwork to Cllr J Evans in respect of the Planning Application for change of use of the land from a play area.   The Legal Notices cannot be published until planning approval has been received from Maidstone Borough Council.   Cllr Coleman asked what the length of the lease is likely to be, Cllr Law confirmed that initially a 35 year period had been requested, but a 99 year lease would now be preferred – the length of the lease would be decided when the contract is drawn up.

46.       Policing

(i)                  Police Liaison Visit – see attached report from PC Thomas

(ii)        Neighbourhood Watch – Cllr Bowker reported that there has been a spate of chain letters which have been passed to PC Thomas.   Three came from abroad which are franked and may be traceable   

47.       Maidstone Borough Council

Cllr Parvin reported changes are being made in respect of re-cycling, which will affect the whole Borough.   He has received approximately 50 letters in respect of the Forestlan / Chestnut Cottage Planning Application, which will go before the MBC Planning Committee.

Cllr Harrison had received a complaint from a resident in respect of a Planning Application submitted to MBC, which has so far taken five months – Cllr Parvin requested Cllr Harrison ask the complainant to write to him in order for him to establish the reason for the delay.

48.       Planning

Applications:

(i)                  MA/06/1206 – Forestlan and Chestnut Cottage, Lenham Road, Kingswood - erection of 9 no. houses – refused at Meeting of Planning Committee, 19/07/06

The Clerk had since received amended / additional details/ landscaping in respect of this application.   After further consideration, it was agreed the original decision to refuse the application should stand, for the same reasons – Clerk to write to MBC accordingly.                                                               ACTION - Clerk

(ii)        MA/06/1201 – 55 Charlesford Avenue, Kingswood - erection of a single storey front and rear extensions and a conservatory – approved at Meeting of Planning Committee, 19/07/06

(iii)       MA/06/1009 – 14 Whitehall Drive, Kingswood - retrospective application for the removal of a 3m high Leylandi Hedge and replacement with a 2m high close board fencing – approved at Meeting of Planning Committee, 19/07/06. 

(iv)       MA/06/1318 -  5 Chestnut Drive, Kingswood – extension of dormer to front elevation to form ensuite – approve                                           ACTION - Clerk

Decisions (MBC):

(i)         MA/06/351 – Street Farm, Chartway Street, East Sutton – erection of single storey building with internal basement area for the expansion of existing trial plant for the manufacture of bio-fuel and associated farm storage - approved

(ii)                MA/06/1011 – Holly Shaw, Lenham Road, Kingswood – erection of a single storey front extension - approved

(iii)               MA/06/1009 – Fairview Barn, Broomfield Road, Broomfield – application for listed building consent for the installation of 2 no. conservation roof-lights to rear of property – refused

(iv)              MA/04/1659 – 19 Chestnut Drive, Kingswood – a loft conversion including the installation of dormer windows to the front and rear – appeal dismissed by the Planning Inspectorate on 19/07/06

(v)                MA/06/0874 – Overhills, Cross Drive, Kingswood – erection of a front extension, removal of existing roof and construction of a new roof with increased ridge height including conversion of a new loft area – refused

(vi)              MA/05/1958 – Land at The Meadows, Chartway Street – erection of a detached 4 bedroom dwelling – appeal dismissed by the Planning Inspectorate on 04/07/06

(vii)      MA/06/0822 – Telecommunications Mast, Land east of Morry Lane, Morry Lane, East Sutton – to install a 20m high single pole headframe monopole telephone mast incorporating 3 no. 2.06m antennas, 1 no. 0.6m and 1 no. 0.3m diameter dishes, radio equipment housing and development ancillary thereto - approved

Other:

            (i)         MA/05/1260 – Land at The Cottage, Gravelly Bottom Road, Kingswood –

                        Outline application for the erection of 1 no. detached bungalow with means of

Access and siting to be considered at this stage to be occupied as an affordable starter home by a young lifetime resident of Kingswood (Resubmission of application MA/05/0378).   Informal Hearing into this Appeal will be held starting 10.0am on 9th August 2006, at Oakwood House, Oakwood Park, Tonbridge Road, Maidstone.   Clerk had previously sent letter of objection in respect of this Application and no Councillor was available to attend this Hearing.

49.       Finance Officer’s Report - Clerk

                                                                                                      £

(i)         Current Account  as at 03/07/06                                200.00

            Reserve Account as at 03/07/06                           42,707.80            

(ii)        Invoices for payment:  

                                                                                                                                                                Chq. No.

            Audit Commission – audit fees 2004                            141.00             1195

            Berry & Co. – audit year ended 31/03/04                     464.12             1196

Clerk – 26th June to 30th July 2006, inc.                       834.28             1197      

KCC – KCS – files, stationery, etc.                                38.76             1198

            Phil Chander – July delivery Echo (cash)                       20.00             Cash

(iii)       Audit Commission - 2004/5 Annual Return

The Clerk had held a meeting with Nigel Cuming, sole applicant in respect of RFO, and appraised him of the current situation re: the accounts and annual returns.   Clerk has also written to the Audit Commission asking for more time in respect of submission of 2004/5 Annual Return, but no reply received to date.   Clerk has checked 2004/5 Invoices file provided by previous Clerk, Ron Harrop, and has established that a total of 23 Invoices for the year are missing, including two from the Audit Commission which upon request, have since supplied duplicate copies of the Invoices concerned.   There are also 3 Invoices missing in respect of payments made to Ron Harrop and it was agreed the Clerk write to Mr Harrop requesting duplicates.                                                        ACTION - Clerk

50.       Kingswood Primary School

(i)         Report on Public Meeting re: proposed amalgamation with Platts Heath

Cllr Evans stated that the Meeting had been widely reported in the Kent Messenger.   Very strong feelings with regard to keeping Platts Heath school open and opposed to the amalgamation with Kingswood.   Sir Sandy Bruce-Lockhart and Hugh Robertson, MP were also opposed to the amalgamation.

(ii)        Consideration re: donation towards Adventure Trail

Cllr Evans believed that most of the village would want to support the Primary School, especially as it had been stated by Emma Hickling, Acting Headteacher, that the Adventure Trail would be made available for use by other organisations such as the Beavers, Cubs, Pre-school, etc.   Cllr Harrison proposed donating the sum of £500 towards this project, seconded by Cllr Evans.   Voted 4 : 2 to donate £500 towards the cost of the Adventure Trail.   Cllr Evans suggested it be made clear in an accompanying letter, that this is an ‘exceptional request’ so as not to be overwhelmed with similar ones.                                                                                 ACTION - Clerk      

51.       Recreation & Sports Field

(i)         Fencing Play Equipment – Cllr Law is still awaiting a quote regarding suitable fencing       

(ii)        Footpath – Cllr Coleman – the forms have been circulated for signing via Cllr Jody Evans   

(iii)       Football Club Contract – the Clerk has now completed and circulated the final draft contract, including additional clauses suggested by Corporate Law, MBC.   One final suggestion made by Cllr Bowker regarding the key to the portacabin to be issued against a deposit, it was agreed to replace the word ‘Contract’ with ‘Licence’ and the Licence to expire 31st May and renew 1st June annually.   Once amended, the Clerk will send the Contract to the Football Club secretary, Mike George.                             ACTION - Clerk

(iv)       ROSPA Inspection - the Clerk has received the report in respect of the play equipment at the Sports Field from ROSPA.   The report identifies a number of areas and items of equipment that are classified ‘low’ or ‘medium’ risk, fail to meet required safety standards, and need attention.   This includes some parts of the recently installed Playdale  play equipment.   Cllr Evans suggested a Meeting of the Sports Field Committee to deal with this issue, Clerk requested to write to Playdale regarding their equipment in this respect, including copy of relevant section of the ROSPA report.                               ACTION - Clerk

(v)        Hedging - Clerk had met with Steven Waring at the Sports Field regarding the planting of a mixed hedge during October/November, and is awaiting his quote           

52.       Roads                      

(i)         Street Monitor – Cllr Coleman reported that Val Clarke has received several complaints regarding the litter bin Chestnut Drive / Whitehall Drive being used for dog waste and overflowing.   Cllr Coleman has contacted MBC Environmental Health with a view to having the bin removed to prevent further misuse.    

(ii)        Dog Bin – Charlesford Avenue – Clerk had received request from a resident living at the western end of Charlesford Avenue, for an additional dog bin to be placed at that end of the village and had offered to have a bin fixed to his fence.   Clerk had contacted Ian Hills, MBC Dog Warden, who confirmed it is not permissible to have dog waste bins sited in residential areas.   Clerk had also requested a new supply of dog waste bags, Ian Hills agreed to deliver two boxes to the Village Store for free use by residents

(iii)       Verges, weeds and street cleansing – Following several complaints from residents regarding overgrown verges, some restricting the view of drivers, and weeds growing in gutters, etc., the Clerk had e-mailed KCC requesting they be cut as a matter of urgency.   Also as requested at Meeting 030706 by Cllr Hendy following street cleansing complaints re: some areas of the village being missed, the Clerk has also ascertained remaining 2006 street cleansing dates for the Parish as follows: (all Mondays) 11th September, 23rd October, 4th December.   There would be no further weed spraying by MBC until October

(iv)       Road signs – Clerk has again reported road name sign defects at Elder Close and Gravelly Bottom Road to MBC (previously reported in February 2006 together with photographs) and additionally incorrect spelling of Bush(e)y Grove.

53.       Village Hall  

Cllr Coleman had attended his first Meeting of the Village Hall committee as Parish Council representative.   Following the Parish Council’s decision to cancel the 2006 Fun Day on 2nd September, a ‘Kingswood Fair’ will be held at the Village Hall in place of the Fun Day.   Next Meeting will be held on 18th September.

54.       Pensioners’ outing

The Clerk has booked the outing for 45 people, for Tuesday 19th September – Spot Hire coach to

K & ESR Tenterden/steam train to Bodium with coffee and pastries served on board/coach

transfer to visit Sissinghurst Castle and Gardens with cream tea/return Kingswood.   Clerk has

displayed notices and handed out application forms and has already had some returned  

55.       Responsible Finance Officer

Cllr Evans reported that following advertising for an RFO, resident Nigel Cuming is the sole

applicant and Cllr Evans hoped Nigel could be appointed this evening in order to progress the

2004/5 accounts as a matter or urgency.   Cllrs Bowker, Lyne and Law spoke of the need for 

references.   Cllr Coleman had spoken with Nigel, and is confident he has the relevant knowledge

and experience.   Cllr Evans then proposed Nigel be appointed as RFO this evening, seconded

by Cllr Harrison, subject to suitable references being supplied by Nigel within three weeks –

agreed unanimously.   Nigel has also applied for the role of Assistant Clerk, but no decision can

be made in this regard until after the closing date for applications as shown in the August Echo.        

56.       Correspondence File

(i)         Clerk had received a letter from resident Ann Ward re: PC Stuart Thomas, enclosing a copy of her letter to Chief Superintendent Hope regarding new Policing proposals which would result in the loss of PC Thomas as the Parish Neighbourhood Officer, and urging the Parish Council to also respond (see 43(i)).      

(ii)        MBC – Freightliner Service dates (Village Hall):

            Saturday 12th August , 10.00am – 11.30am

Sunday 1st October, 3.00pm – 4.00pm 

                Saturday 18th November, 10.00am  – 11.30am

The Clerk reported that the Freightliner had failed to attend on Saturday 5th August due to a new Contract from 31st July, resulting in a change of schedule and all attendances having been moved forward by one week.   The Clerk is assured the Freightliner will attend on the above dates.

(iii)       Clerk had received a letter from Maidstone Borough Council regarding the review of the ‘Parks & Open Spaces Byelaws’.   Agreed Clerk to write and confirm that Broomfield and Kingswood Parish wishes to be included in the newly created Byelaws, and requesting a draft copy of same.                                                                                                            ACTION – Clerk

(iv)       Invitation received from Mayor Mike Fitzgerald, to attend his Charity Dinner Dance on Sunday 27th August at Russell Hotel, Maidstone – Clerk has details for anyone interested

57.       Items for next Meeting’s Agenda

(i)         Request for funding from Kingswood Pre-School – Cllr Hendy

(ii)        Apologies for absence from Cllrs Coleman and M Evans - holiday

58.       Any Other Business

(i)         Jan Enever, Editor of the K&B Village News, had contacted the Clerk regarding the non-publication of The Echo on the four months the Village News is published, i.e. March, June, September and December.   Cllr Law stated he had held an initial meeting with Jan, but did not recall this agreement.   Jan had also expressed concern regarding the loss of revenue from advertising, as adverts are now appearing in The Echo at a lower cost.   This could result in the Parish Council having to pay more towards the printing of the Village News.   Cllr Coleman had received comments that The Echo had lost its impact since accepting advertisements as there correspondingly less space to include information.   Cllr Evans proposed that The Echo should not be published on these months and that advertising no longer be included, seconded by Cllr Coleman, and agreed by all.            

(ii)        Cllr Lyne has reported that in a cupboard at the Village Hall, are some items belonging to the Parish Council, left over from previously run summer Play Schemes.   These include racquets and bats, pots of paint, etc.   It has been suggested that these items could be offered to   Kingswood Primary School and/or the Scout Group for their use, if suitable.   There are also some bags containing confidential paperwork, including details of children attending the Play Schemes, which the Clerk has offered to shred for safe disposal.   It was discussed and agreed that Cllr Lyne dispose of these items as suggested above, and that the Clerk should shred any confidential documents, as stated.                                                             ACTION – PL / Clerk

(iii)       Cllr Bowker raised the issue of a large bunch of keys held by the previous Clerk, Ron

Harrop, but which appear to have been retained.   Clerk to write to Mr Harrop requesting the

return of these keys                                                                                        ACTION - Clerk

(iv)       The Clerk reminded the Meeting that she will not be able to attend the next Meeting on 4th

September due to being on holiday, and offered her apologies.   Cllr Lyne offered to take the

Minutes at this Meeting.  This was agreed by all, and Cllr Law thanked Cllr Lyne for taking this on.

(v)        The Clerk is in receipt of (and using) the new Parish Council laptop, Invoice in respect of

this has not yet been received.  The laser printer/copier is on order and delivery is expected

shortly.

59.       Parish Council Meetings

The next Meeting of the Parish Council will be held at Kingswood Village Hall on Monday

4th September 2006 at 7.30pm.  

Cllr Law closed the Meeting at 11.27pm.

____________________________________________________________